Brake disc life.

Highlander

Active Member
Mar 16, 2016
18
10
My 64-plate FR 184 DSG needs new discs and pads. It's only done 23k miles, fur fox ache! Anyone else think that's a hopeless lifespan for brakes? I used to drive big, heavy SAABs and Volvos, and I wouldn't have expected to change discs under 60k. I live right by the sea, so salty air is an issue, but even so. Still, at least part are cheaper for the SEAT, and fixed-price servicing avoids surprises.
 

DEAN0

Old Git
Feb 1, 2006
5,439
1
425
Preston - UK
Still, at least part are cheaper for the SEAT, and fixed-price servicing avoids surprises.

I think that explains it better.

They always add as much extra chargeable work as possible to the bare minimum they do under the fixed price service.

I was told my discs were getting close to replacement at 27k
Myself and the local MOT station decided that was Bo**ox

I would get a second opinion.
 

Highlander

Active Member
Mar 16, 2016
18
10
I think that explains it better.

I would get a second opinion.

They're definitely fubar. I can see that myself, just by looking.... and they're making a noise unlike I've experienced in 35 years driving. :)
 

DEAN0

Old Git
Feb 1, 2006
5,439
1
425
Preston - UK
They're definitely fubar. I can see that myself, just by looking.... and they're making a noise unlike I've experienced in 35 years driving. :)

Have you considered a move up to the 340mm setup ?

If you have gone through the fronts in 23k - perhaps you need the bigger brakes.
 

silles

Active Member
May 4, 2017
517
89
i did 50k in my Toyota TS before needed new disks....
haven't dont enough in the Leon.

I tend not to use the brakes, just the engine to slow down. that more fun, more mpg and less break wear
 

silles

Active Member
May 4, 2017
517
89
A set of discs and pads is so much cheaper than a fitted clutch

downshifting does not have much clutch wear... especially if u rev match ( i don't)

I had the car for 7 years/80k and clutch was ok
 

salsajoe

Active Member
Apr 12, 2017
130
13
Yorkshire
My 64-plate FR 184 DSG needs new discs and pads. It's only done 23k miles, fur fox ache! Anyone else think that's a hopeless lifespan for brakes? I used to drive big, heavy SAABs and Volvos, and I wouldn't have expected to change discs under 60k. I live right by the sea, so salty air is an issue, but even so. Still, at least part are cheaper for the SEAT, and fixed-price servicing avoids surprises.

I think disc wear is in part down to weather conditions. Sounds like you live north of the border so salt etc will cause corrosion and reduce disc life. I always give my car a run after washing to dry the discs. The inside of the discs always takes a while to dry because of the disc shield. Even so 23k seems very low. My GTI is on 67k and still original discs and pads.
 

Highlander

Active Member
Mar 16, 2016
18
10
I live literally on the seafront. Salt spray is everywhere, so not much hope of washing doing anything. Even so, 23k is just dreadful lifespan for discs, imo.

Sent from my Nexus 5X using Tapatalk
 

BreadlyBrown

Active Member
Jan 24, 2013
281
6
Southampton
I live literally on the seafront. Salt spray is everywhere, so not much hope of washing doing anything. Even so, 23k is just dreadful lifespan for discs, imo.

Sent from my Nexus 5X using Tapatalk
I would agree with DEAN0's suggestion of a second opinion. Especially if you are on first set of pads too? Discs won't wear out quicker than pads!

MK3 Leon ST Cupra 290 Black Edition
 

NotApplicable

Newbie....at my age?????
Mar 26, 2016
100
5
Somerset
The problem you have with comparing mileage is that you need to look for equivalent driving style. I am at 41k on the first set of discs (showing no signs of needing replacement) and the second set of pads. I do a lot of motorway and dual-carriageway driving with small stints of beating the sugar honey, iced tea out of them.

If the car has done a lot of hard acceleration and hard braking, well, that's a whole different kettle of fish.
 

NotApplicable

Newbie....at my age?????
Mar 26, 2016
100
5
Somerset
BTW, I had to replace the disks on my Mk1 Leon after 25k due to warped disks. I could tell this was true due to trying to spin the wheels whilst jacked up. So, sometimes things just fail.....
 

Major Tom

Active Member
Jun 6, 2015
230
8
If you drive like a girl and the brakes wear out despite of that, try use OBD11 to turn off the periodical auto-braking that is supposed to remove rainwater.
 

'& Son' managed

Third Party
Mar 2, 2018
270
89
South Coast
It's worth remembering that it's been noted for a few years now that brake discs do wear more quickly compared to the average of years ago. Mostly due to changes in brake pad compounds and their interaction with the discs so I've read.
 

martin j.

Active Member
Feb 11, 2007
1,997
894
Fife
Discs wear quicker now that the pad material has been changed to a more eco friendly material, no asbestos more heavy metals, my Honda has had a busy life, 32k miles=2 sets of pads and a set of discs ,heading for a third set of pads soon, it's all in how it's driven, autos also tend to wear pads/discs quicker.

When I learned to drive ( many moons ago) I was taught. gears to go-brakes to slow, brake down to speed then change down into the appropriate gear.