I would go for the beamer, I have had my Leon FR+ for 6 years and on average have had a major fault once a year. It's a 55 plate and I had a new cam at 107,000 so the chocy cam still exists. It is actually in the
garage today for a burst heater matrix.
They are a nice car to drive, but badly designed/built. Most seem to suffer from cabin rattle, leaky door seals and egr valve blockage as well as many other common faults.