• Hey Guest👍👎 We're looking for reviews of your local CUPRA or SEAT Dealership - it's quick and easy to do: Leave a review now

Shrako

Active Member
Jun 19, 2012
20
0
Bulgaria
Howdy fellas,

I am in the market of buying a Cupra estate and given the pretty much same cash value on the market, I would love to get an opinion on which one should I go for, since currently on the market locally for me there are 0 of either, so going for a drive and figuring it for myself is difficult - it will be an import.

To give you some background my car history includes:
An Ibiza 1.2 Sys Porsche
My first car - a '97 1.6 Cordoba
An 01 Cordoba Cupra
An 01 Leon Cupra 4R.

After a whole bunch of Seats, I ended up getting a 01 1.8T Skoda Octy 4x4, which I still own, but is currently pretty much just a track car.
8 years ago I met a gal, whose parents lived across the country on the seaside and when we were young we used to go every other weekend (550ish kms). Doing so many long highway trips made me sell the Cupras and get a proper boat. Ended up with an '15 Jag XF 3.0 SC AWD. It did its part and covered many miles with no effort (especially after doing dual pulleys on it), but nowadays we have a kid, travel much less frequently, but we do it with a lot of luggage and mostly on B-roads. Hence a fun to drive estate kind of is exactly what I need.

Question is - is there someone around who has gone from a 3.5 (preferrably an R) to a Mk4?

I have a feeling the matherials in the MK3.5 are actually nicer, but I guess the older platform is a bit worse in NVH. Whichever I get, I will probably throw some extra soundproofing and of course is getting at least a hybrid turbo.

Any input is welcome, thanks.
 
Had an R ST from new for 5 years, now in a VZ3 ST 333. What do you want to know.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
How would the two compare?
Is the R much shaper to drive?
Is the new gen much quieter/comfier?
Am I right in assuming the R has less scratchy plastics then the newer?
Basically, is there anything where one is extremely better than the other?
 
The R was set up better for fast road. The brakes had more feel than the gen4 even though I would say ultimately the gen4 has more stopping power once you stomp on them. There’s very little difference in cabin noise.

The main difference with the new one is it’s just a nicer place to be. The whole cabin has a feeling of quality and more toys like electric seats, heated steering wheel and the infotainment system is leagues ahead. The fit and finish is far superior to the R.

Once the boffins crack the E888 coding you’ll be over 400bhp with a stage 1 tune - I’m looking forward to that.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Thanks,

That kinda make sense - the R had the special knuckles for the extra camber and overall moat bushings on the front are harder than the ones on the mk4 afaik. Generally the same is doable to a mk4 using the golf clubsport knuckles.

Are you running the optional Akebonos?

Yeah, the evo4 engine does sound rather nice with the bigger continental turbo, at least to a certain power level, then the lack of port injection is a bit of a stab in the back.

I am surprised by the cabin noise, I thought that thanks to stuff like laminated side glass the new one would be leagues ahead.

The multimedia comment hit the nail on the head, the one on the R is probably the biggest stop for me right now, I really hate how they handled it on the Leon, especially given that the Gold and Octavia got the much better 9.2 inch one in a more traditional location.
 
Yes I’m on Akebonos. I suppose the cabin noise is subjective but to me there’s not much difference.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk