Chris Knott Insurance - Competitive quotes for forum members

Cambelt change

hanxslf

Guest
My Altea 2.0 TDI Sport is due a cambelt change, 4 years are up but not the mileage 37K.
I have had a quote of £273:-o, buy a local independent garage, this this quote includes the tensioner as well, using genuine Seat parts
Is this a reasonable quote ?
I'm going to phone the Seat dealer i got the Altea from tomorrow for a quote to compare.
Anyone had theirs done? Any advice welcome
 

hanxslf

Guest
Phoned DAVID PENMANS SEAT in Darlington today and they have quoted me £260, for the same job
Just goes to show not all independent service garage's are cheaper than the main dealers.:happy:
 

hanxslf

Guest
Yeah a good price so i booked it in with them for next week, apparently they are doing an offer on cam belt replacement at the moment.
 

hanxslf

Guest
andyj said:
that's not a bad price for a main dealer to be honest.

my LCR was going to cost me about £500 from a main dealer.... ended up getting JBS to do it for about £350 (inc water pump)
Click to expand...

Thanks andyj
Water pump
just been looking through the forum, looks like it's recommended to change this item while it's in bits.
I will phone dealer tomorrow to see what they say
 
dlm2310

dlm2310

Rocco Is God !!
Dec 17, 2006
164
0
West Yorkshire
Mine is 4 years up in March and has done 60,500.

Got it booked in at a local indy in Thirsk at the end of Feb, fingers crossed it doesn't go before then !!!
 

hanxslf

Guest
dlm2310 said:
Mine is 4 years up in March and has done 60,500.

Got it booked in at a local indy in Thirsk at the end of Feb, fingers crossed it doesn't go before then !!!
Click to expand...

I live in Thirsk, which Indy are you takingit to ? I took my last car to Wakes at Northallerton
But they quoted me more than the main dealer for the cambelt, hence it's going to the main dealer

mine has 37K on clock, it's going in to David Penmans at Darlington this week also getting water pump replaced. I have found on other posts on this site that the pump can fail around 60K or 40K at worst.
All in the cost £329.69
 
dlm2310

dlm2310

Rocco Is God !!
Dec 17, 2006
164
0
West Yorkshire
hanxslf said:
I live in Thirsk, which Indy are you takingit to ? I took my last car to Wakes at Northallerton
But they quoted me more than the main dealer for the cambelt, hence it's going to the main dealer

mine has 37K on clock, it's going in to David Penmans at Darlington this week also getting water pump replaced. I have found on other posts on this site that the pump can fail around 60K or 40K at worst.
All in the cost £329.69
Click to expand...

Hi,

I'm taking it to Station Auto services at Carlton Minniott, been taking my cars there for the last 10 years or so.
Good set of lads and never been ripped off hence been going there for years.

The Altea will be having it's 3rd service with them whilst it's there.

My parents live in Sowerby and I live in Bradford so i travel a fair way to get the servicing done but it's worthwhile as I can trust them to do a good job.
 

hanxslf

Guest
dlm2310 said:
Hi,

I'm taking it to Station Auto services at Carlton Minniott, been taking my cars there for the last 10 years or so.
Good set of lads and never been ripped off hence been going there for years.

The Altea will be having it's 3rd service with them whilst it's there.

My parents live in Sowerby and I live in Bradford so i travel a fair way to get the servicing done but it's worthwhile as I can trust them to do a good job.
Click to expand...

Hi,
I actually live in Sowerby (near big school), but i always post Thirsk on forums,
I have never used Station Autos, but i have never heard anything bad. I suppose if your happy with the service of your garage you will keep going back.
I have used wakes at northallerton for a good few years now but is seems their prices are as much as dealers now or more for my cambelt change
 
dlm2310

dlm2310

Rocco Is God !!
Dec 17, 2006
164
0
West Yorkshire
hanxslf said:
Hi,
I actually live in Sowerby (near big school), but i always post Thirsk on forums,
I have never used Station Autos, but i have never heard anything bad. I suppose if your happy with the service of your garage you will keep going back.
I have used wakes at northallerton for a good few years now but is seems their prices are as much as dealers now or more for my cambelt change
Click to expand...

Yeah my parents live on Front St.

I bought my car from JCT600 in Yeadon and have had apalling service from them, then used Richard Alexander (now bust) in Huddersfield, all during when the car was in warranty.

There was no way I was paying dealer prices but like you say the price you have been quoted sounds good.

My 40k service at Station auto services was £120 and 50k was £400 but that included 2 new tyres, rear pads and other niggly stuff.

I suppose cambelts are one of those things where you can't be too careful with. Yours has done 23k less than mine and may have ooo's left in it but is just not worth the risk.

There are so many different opinions on this, Station Autos said it was 80k or 4 years and I've read on other forums where it is 60k or 4 years for a visual check and then checks at 20k intervals and a change at 110k, but that's no comfort if a visual check is OK at 60k and it snaps at 65k !!
 
jtmac

jtmac

Active Member
Dec 4, 2006
155
1
Bradford, W Yorks
www.bigdaydigital.co.uk
There was a recommendation of a garage in Wyke (in Bradford) on this board not too long ago. I've not used them but was going to get my cambelt done there soon. I'll have to do a search and find them.

dlm2310 - did you see that thread?
 
dlm2310

dlm2310

Rocco Is God !!
Dec 17, 2006
164
0
West Yorkshire
jtmac said:
There was a recommendation of a garage in Wyke (in Bradford) on this board not too long ago. I've not used them but was going to get my cambelt done there soon. I'll have to do a search and find them.

dlm2310 - did you see that thread?
Click to expand...

No didn't see it but if you manage to find out then please let me know
 

CrispDust

Dec 5, 2007
888
1
N W Leeds
Aftyer expensive experience I would never put a cambelt past 40k or 4 years.. Its a bit of reinforced rubber that is the only thing that stops your engine smashing itself to pieces.
Rubber perishes over time and exposure to all the crap on our roads.
 

CrispDust

Dec 5, 2007
888
1
N W Leeds
Garage in Wyke could be Westend Autos - Iuse them for my MOTs and trye changes.
Guys that run/own it seem to be honest and hardworking and efficiently run.
 
dlm2310

dlm2310

Rocco Is God !!
Dec 17, 2006
164
0
West Yorkshire
CrispDust said:
Aftyer expensive experience I would never put a cambelt past 40k or 4 years.. Its a bit of reinforced rubber that is the only thing that stops your engine smashing itself to pieces.
Rubber perishes over time and exposure to all the crap on our roads.
Click to expand...

40k is a bit excessive mate, I'd be changing mine every 2 and a half years.

Have you just been unlucky ?
 
dlm2310

dlm2310

Rocco Is God !!
Dec 17, 2006
164
0
West Yorkshire
hanxslf said:
Hi,
I actually live in Sowerby (near big school), but i always post Thirsk on forums,
I have never used Station Autos, but i have never heard anything bad. I suppose if your happy with the service of your garage you will keep going back.
I have used wakes at northallerton for a good few years now but is seems their prices are as much as dealers now or more for my cambelt change
Click to expand...

All done today, Cambelt change, new tensioners & water pump - £275

Great service.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

timlee
New here – Need help finding a good mechanic for cambelt change (SEAT Mii)
Replies
1
Views
304
Syphon
Syphon
09 Seat XL 1.9 Diesel Boost Issue
Replies
1
Views
488
Halliwell2003
2.0TDI cambelt/pump change dates
Replies
11
Views
1K
BillyCool
BillyCool
pufius
Altea XL DSG gearbox problem
Replies
0
Views
1K
pufius
pufius
Altea XL 2009 2.0 TDI BKD - New owner, two head scratching issues.
Replies
1
Views
691
littlehomer
Top Bottom