They are meant to be a single use item, ie replaced rather than refitted. It's a "plastic" sump plug and a "plastic" (PA6 35% glass fibre reinforced) sump.
The design of the plug is meant to make it impossible (!) to over-torque when fitting and so damage the sump. The threads are coarse and there's an o-ring to
help sealing, there's no need to torque the plug because the lug on it snaps into place to secure it.
You can see it in this photo.
When people use a screwdriver to remove the old plug it often gets distorted, hence best to replace it, using the
correct tool to remove it reduces the chances of damage, at the very least replace the o-ring.
Given the cost just fit a new plug... or use an extractor to drain the oil in which case the whole sump plug renewal question is irrelevant.