I'm sure mine had some kind of foam / sponge seal around the lip - it was quite a nice snug fit, however it's possible yours sn't sat on the hole properly. Each time it rains, the water fills up and spills over the edge into the car.
The foam is there just wet and spongy making a squelch sound when pressed down, thing is I have never had a leak in this area at all since owning the car, only thing is that the car has been jacked up to have the wheels changed yesterday, unless that has moved something out of line?
