• Hey Guest👍👎 We're looking for reviews of your local CUPRA or SEAT Dealership - it's quick and easy to do: Leave a review now
Dec 6, 2024
251
221
www.swanswaygarages.com
When it comes to choosing your next car, where do you sit on the performance vs efficiency debate?

Would you rather have the extra power and sharper performance when you want it, even if it means sacrificing a little on fuel economy?

Or is fuel efficiency, running costs and getting the most miles from every tank/charge more important to you?

And has your view changed over the years? Maybe performance was the priority when you were younger, but practicality and efficiency matter more now… or perhaps you still want that extra punch whenever you put your foot down!

Performance or efficiency — where do you sit? And what car have you got that best balances the two?
 
My views have certainly changed with advancing age. I’m more focused on economy rather than performance these days, although the opposite used to be the case for me.

I’ve owned mainly hot hatches during the (almost) 50 years that I’ve been driving, but my current car is a modest B segment full - self charging - hybrid (not a VAG car). I’ve been retired a few years now and pretty much all of my motoring is local in the area I live with most of my journeys are no more than a 50-60 mile round trip. The roads I drive on are predominantly A and B single carriageway roads and they always seem to be pretty congested with traffic usually travelling at 45 - 55 mph max with little or no opportunity to overtake or use the performance potential of a performance-oriented car, so it’s a case of just going with the flow of the traffic. Under those driving conditions, my lowly hybrid is as quick as the rest of the traffic.

I don’t really miss not owning a performance car these days, and a long term average fuel consumption of circa 67 mpg from my current car is an added bonus! 👍🙂

My next car is likely to be a B segement EV.
 
My views have certainly changed with advancing age. I’m more focused on economy rather than performance these days, although the opposite used to be the case for me.

I’ve owned mainly hot hatches during the (almost) 50 years that I’ve been driving, but my current car is a modest B segment full - self charging - hybrid (not a VAG car). I’ve been retired a few years now and pretty much all of my motoring is local in the area I live with most of my journeys are no more than a 50-60 mile round trip. The roads I drive on are predominantly A and B single carriageway roads and they always seem to be pretty congested with traffic usually travelling at 45 - 55 mph max with little or no opportunity to overtake or use the performance potential of a performance-oriented car, so it’s a case of just going with the flow of the traffic. Under those driving conditions, my lowly hybrid is as quick as the rest of the traffic.

I don’t really miss not owning a performance car these days, and a long term average fuel consumption of circa 67 mpg from my current car is an added bonus! 👍🙂

My next car is likely to be a B segement EV.
That’s a really good point – there’s not much benefit in having lots of power if the roads and traffic don’t give you the opportunity to enjoy it! A hybrid sounds like a great balance for everyday driving, especially with 67mpg. It’ll be interesting to see how your move to an EV compares.

Do you think you’ll miss the convenience of a self-charging hybrid, or are you looking forward to going fully electric?
 
I would personally add a third item - Reliability in my personal view we are seeing more and more cars getting much more tech in them and this is leading to issues with user interaction, failing sensors and hardware that stops working correctly so personally I am looking for performance (not for road use but track use) however I would be paying a lot of attention to how many issues a particular model / manufacturer are having with new cars as well as recent releases.
 
It's a balance, whatever I find "reasonable" for my needs / preferences and economy. Going to pick up Cupra Raval next week to me I found the basic VZ model's DCC & eLSD and slightly extra power desireable for little extra added cost but I didn't wanna sacrifice the range going for performance tyres with the VZ Extreme model with "C" efficiency rating, seemed like a rather big drop to me from 440 km to 380 km WLTP only by the tyre option alone, I'm not a track racer that needs that little bit extra grip, for me the tyre difference go a little too much into marginal performance gains for a significant range penalty that I didn't find attractive at all, especially as 440 km WLTP, while good for a B segment class car, it sits for me borderline of the minimum range I was looking for as a primary car (I drive 95% around town but occassionally nearby towns so it should be okay but I don't wanna have to stop to charge in winter while 380 km WLTP on a cold winter day might be cutting it a bit short and probably 200~250 km or something actual range in -20C or so with up to 80 km/h speeds that is the limit on countryside roads during winter here so the 60 km or so extra range adds welcomed headroom.

EDIT: now this became more of a hypothetical example as I will be driving with nordic non-studded 18" Goodyear Alu Ultragrip Ice 3 tyres eitherway in winter with whatever range those will have, depending on dimensions seems to be classified A or B for efficiency (what I've read very efficient for winter tyre with pleasant handling).
 
Last edited:
That’s a really good point – there’s not much benefit in having lots of power if the roads and traffic don’t give you the opportunity to enjoy it! A hybrid sounds like a great balance for everyday driving, especially with 67mpg. It’ll be interesting to see how your move to an EV compares.

Do you think you’ll miss the convenience of a self-charging hybrid, or are you looking forward to going fully electric?

I may well miss the convenience of a self charging hybrid. The move to an EV isn’t a 100% certainty and I may go for another self charging hybrid; I’ve owned the current one for just over two years and it’s been pretty much faultless.
 
If I had to choose one or the other, it would be performance. However electric cars can also offer a blend of both, albeit they can be a little sterile in there application.

I have the Raval VZ on order, as I think that is a good blend of both, but I would class that as a mild performamce car with efficiency rather than a performance car. I will be keeping my current car, a 2016 RSQ3, which is performance with no efficiency lol

Getting the Raval and keeping the RS was non negotiable, the wife understands that (y)
 
Speed Driving GIF


..... only because I don't do many miles these days :)
 
I quite like the balance in the Born, quick enough for a road car but still able to maintain a decent range.

As mentioned though, reliability is up there on the list, down to lack of bugs in the infotainment - definitely one area VAG need to work on still. It's getting there, but still plenty of niggles that ruin the experience somewhat.
 
If I had to choose one or the other, it would be performance. However electric cars can also offer a blend of both, albeit they can be a little sterile in there application.

I have the Raval VZ on order, as I think that is a good blend of both, but I would class that as a mild performamce car with efficiency rather than a performance car. I will be keeping my current car, a 2016 RSQ3, which is performance with no efficiency lol

Getting the Raval and keeping the RS was non negotiable, the wife understands that (y)
That's a pretty good combination to have! The Raval VZ sounds like an interesting choice, especially if it can give you a bit of performance without sacrificing too much efficiency. And keeping the RSQ3 definitely means you're not giving up on the fun side of things!

I think that's where the balance gets interesting. Do you reckon the Raval will surprise you with its performance, or will the RSQ3 always be the one you take out when you fancy a proper drive? And has the electric side of things won you over at all?
 
I quite like the balance in the Born, quick enough for a road car but still able to maintain a decent range.

As mentioned though, reliability is up there on the list, down to lack of bugs in the infotainment - definitely one area VAG need to work on still. It's getting there, but still plenty of niggles that ruin the experience somewhat.
That's a good point. The Born seems to hit a nice sweet spot – plenty quick enough for everyday driving without constantly worrying about range.
It's interesting how much the little things like infotainment can affect the overall ownership experience too.
Have the software niggles been a regular issue for you, or have things improved with updates? Do you think you'd stick with an EV for your next car?
 
To be honest a cars performance and efficency rating is also dependable on the performance and efficiency of the manufacturers dealerships and after my experience of using 3 of them so far I consider them to be pretty poor!
That's a fair point, and something that can definitely make or break the ownership experience! A great car can quickly lose its appeal if the dealership experience lets it down. It's a shame when the aftersales side doesn't live up to the product itself.
What do you think they need to improve most?
 
That's a pretty good combination to have! The Raval VZ sounds like an interesting choice, especially if it can give you a bit of performance without sacrificing too much efficiency. And keeping the RSQ3 definitely means you're not giving up on the fun side of things!

I think that's where the balance gets interesting. Do you reckon the Raval will surprise you with its performance, or will the RSQ3 always be the one you take out when you fancy a proper drive? And has the electric side of things won you over at all?
They are completely different. The RS has all the drama when you want it, but is also a nice everyday car when not. It is however expensive to run around in, mid to high teens around town and low 30's on a run. It is also almost 10 years old too so needs treating with care.
The Raval on the other hand is new, roomier than you would believe and also more sprightly than the performance figures suggest. It also has a really nice cabin and all the modern tech.
I've hired a couple of VW ID cars for holidays and so I have experienced electric driving and its quite a relaxing experience in comparison. Also a LOT cheaper to run when charging at home.
 
That's a fair point, and something that can definitely make or break the ownership experience! A great car can quickly lose its appeal if the dealership experience lets it down. It's a shame when the aftersales side doesn't live up to the product itself.
What do you think they need to improve most?
The following forms the basis of my experience of Cupra dealerships - what do you think they need to do to improve?

I bought my 6 month old Formentor from Marshall Cupra of Leicester it was a Cupra approved vehicle, they agreed to service it as part of the sale but on taking ownership I discovered they hadn`t serviced it I had to complain to Cupra Customer Service and I had to get it serviced locally as it was a 50 mile round trip back to Marshall, the Marshall Salesman had forged my signature on the Sale Invoice which indicated that my Formentor had been exchanged and the sale of the new one had been completed when it hadn`t.

Then 12 months later my latest Formentor went into Listers Cupra Worcester for a service they used 5w-30 engine oil instead of the recommended 0w-30 oil as "it is the same oil" according to their factory trained "Technician" they didn`t cancel the service indicator and didn`t enter the service in the digital service record, I have just had the next service completed at Listers Cupra of Coventry they decided a battery constantly dropping charge over night to below 12 volts was a good battery coincidentally the 3 year warranty was due to expire in a fortnight, they did a vehicle visual health check and on the work sheet it was noted that at 3 years old the brake fluid was tested as satisfactory, the DSG gearbox and 4wd Haldex transmission were also both due a service but they didn`t do it so they ignored the 3 year service schedule on those 3 counts, they didn`t address the fact the Stop Start System was no longer working it wasn`t working when I took the Formentor in and it wasn`t working when it was handed back to me, they acknowledged the "Panoramic Sunroof was quite noisy and needed some "special grease" on the seals but they didn`t have any grease - "you will have to book it in again when we have some grease in stock!"

What a complete shocking shower for Cupra dealerships, I spoke to Cupra Customer Services on various items but to be honest the response was one of couldn`t care less!

With regard to the brake fluid, DSG box, Haldex transmission and Sunroof as it is due out of warranty I would prefer it is serviced correctly so I`ll do it myself!