Craigbarnley

Active Member
Oct 13, 2008
122
0
Cheltenham
Just had my cars mot done and it has failed because the rear disc is corroded? I thought this was a common problem !now having to have new rear discs!

Anybody else had this problem?

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
My rears are also bad, id say a good 10-15mm around the outta edge. Its passed 3mot's like that so :confused: im thinking its down to the tester being more of a 'Fail' vs 'Advisory' sort of guy. Mind you dont all MK4's, Polo's & Fabia's suffer from this...design fault? (because of the small footprint of the pads)

Now ive said that mine will fail in March :whistle::happy:
 
Last edited:
I left my car standing over the xmas bad weather and noticed the rear disks went really bright orange / brown. :cry:

I decided the take it out to clear them and i had just got going when a delivery van pulled out of the kerb right in front of me, i hit the brakes hard and ................... nothing bloody happened :-o

After that i drove a couple of hundred yards with the handbrake lightly on (donging all the way :rolleyes:) and the brakes where fine after that.

Of all the cars ive had, including a Polo, none corrode like this MK4 beezer :cry:
 
My rears are also bad, id say a good 10-15mm around the outta edge. Its passed 3mot's like that so :confused: im thinking its down to the tester being more of a 'Fail' vs 'Advisory' sort of guy. Mind you dont all MK4's, Polo's & Fabia's suffer from this...design fault? (because of the small footprint of the pads)

Now ive said that mine will fail in March :whistle::happy:

I'm sure they pretty much put a gauge on the disc and if it is thinner than the limit (not sure what it will be) it will pass/fail.

Unless of course like I said at the beginning it is actually fouling somewhere?
 
I'm sure they pretty much put a gauge on the disc and if it is thinner than the limit (not sure what it will be) it will pass/fail.

Unless of course like I said at the beginning it is actually fouling somewhere?

This is the common MK4 Ibiza fault That the OP is talking about


img00049201007031715.jpg


img00048201007031715.jpg


img00047201007031714.jpg


img00046201007031714.jpg


Evidence of poor pad to disc contact is an MOT fail. No amount of driving with the handbrake on 1 or 2 clicks will fix this. It should have been spotted a long time ago and then maybe the handbrake trick will work.
 
I left my car standing over the xmas bad weather and noticed the rear disks went really bright orange / brown. :cry:

I decided the take it out to clear them and i had just got going when a delivery van pulled out of the kerb right in front of me, i hit the brakes hard and ................... nothing bloody happened :-o

After that i drove a couple of hundred yards with the handbrake lightly on (donging all the way :rolleyes:) and the brakes where fine after that.

Of all the cars ive had, including a Polo, none corrode like this MK4 beezer :cry:

Thats a bit strange, on my car the fronts do most of the work so having corroded rear discs wouldn't have left me with no brakes.
 
Thats a bit strange, on my car the fronts do most of the work so having corroded rear discs wouldn't have left me with no brakes.

You're overlooking the fact that a rear pad suddenly moving a distance towards the disc can take up most of the action of one brake pedal push.

Similarly, a rear pad stuck on can boil the brake fluid, giving a sudden no-pedal.
 
Thats a bit strange, on my car the fronts do most of the work so having corroded rear discs wouldn't have left me with no brakes.

Oh iam sure the fronts were just as bad and thats why it did not stop :(

I did a few hard pull ups when i got the chance to clear the fronts ;)