• Hi Guest we, are working on an upgrade to the forum this week, meaning the service may be unreliable at times and there will be some planned downtime at some point. Stay updated on this thread.
  • Guest, 🚨New Stock alert: Premium CUPRA valve caps now available in the store 👉 Order now from the merchandise store

Ibiza 1.6TDI CR - Mini Review

jonjay

50 Years of 911
Jun 27, 2005
5,842
1
Essex
New Addition to the Family
-----

I dont really post in this forum section (probably will do now) but out of the various options from Ford, Alfa, Vauxhall etc...we chose a Seat Ibiza to sister the Leon I have.

Picking up the misses mk5 Ibiza 1.6TDI CR, I am really pleased that the car has had no issues and was perfect when we picked it up. The dealer cleaned the car...I told them initially not to do this but changed my mind as thats part of the checks they do to avoid any potential issues. As I detail cars as a hobby I will be machining the car and making sure its even more gleamy for the summer. I noticed some light polishing marks that will easily come out under direct sun light but that shouldnt be much of a problem.

Extras we got are
- Bluetooth
- Folding Mirrors
- Metalic paint
- 17" alloys
- Cruise Control
- USB/Aux ipod connection

Mrs and I been driving it all day and boy are we pleased with it. :)

Handling
The mk5 chassis is superb. Its really responsive and turns in lovely so driving around town and on bendy a roads is a real joy. I think the inclusion of anti roll bars is a brilliant decision by Seat as the car corners pretty flat (ok not like the Leon but hey how much have I spent on modding it) and the sport suspension is pretty compliant. The car eats up nasty roads without to much fuss which gives you a refreshing feeling as you worry less hence relax more. Looking at the car for what it is and NOT trying to compare it to the Leon in terms of abilities (two different beast completely). I would give it a 4.5/5 at the moment.

EDIT: Come to think of it, the sports suspension is a little over-sprung but thats common in Seat range imo.

Build Quality
What can I say, the build quality is definitely a stage up from the last ibiza. Better plastics, better switch gear, better put together, better seats...Everything thuds nicely and doesn't feel flimsy. My only complaint would be a little to much plastic but hey its a small hatch. I noticed that the glovebox wasn't that great, the rear view mirror looks cheap and handles arn't good quality like Leon but again its a small hatch so these things are to be expected.

When driving everything feels solid and you get lovely thuds of reassurance. 4/5 Build quality

Performance
This is a little difficult for me because in my mind I am always going to compare it to the Leon, 240-245ish bhp and 360-380lb/ft vs 105bhp and 184lb/ft. I will try and be as honest and impartial as possible.

Common Rail engine is engine is much quieter than PD engine and you can hardly noticed it when driving. The power delivery is smooth and you get nice pace from 1.5-3k rpms. Being such as "small" car the torque gives the car lovely urgency in 2nd and 3rd so makes town driving and A-road driving quite pleasant. I noticed the Mrs (coming from a corsa 1.2) loving the grunt coming out of the bends and using the torque to accelerate the car on the straight bits. Ok we are not talking blistering speed and the power does die quickly after 3.5k but its a lighter car than the Leon so doesn't underwhelm you.

One concern I have is there really isn't much grunt in 4th and 5th unless you are in the 2k-2.5k range. This sometime can cause a problimo if you get slowed down in traffic so you have to change down. 1st gear hasn't got much guts although sometimes it did. Not sure if its because engine hasn't bedded in yet but I am sure there is more performance to come. Also we have been driving the car cautiously as again new engine so being sensible is a priority.

Motorway driving is really good. Car feels solid, comfortable and goes when you want to go. Going from 60-80mph on an overtake is very easy. When getting slow up in traffic down changing from 5th to 4th is smooth...in fact up changing and down changing is smooth full stop. This obviously helps the overall experience.

Economy is amazing. 50mpg town driving? WTF? All in all its perfect for the Mrs as she can go shopping, drive to her friends out in the sticks, go to Tesco and the occasional motorway drive. :)

4/5

Summary
I am even more pleased than the Mrs and it inst even my car! Not sure if its cause its newer car but I am not missing the Leon much at all. The car ticks all the boxes you could ever want from a small car and I really can see the attraction of getting a FR/Cupra model. In fact with the 1.6CR TDI being so good in handling/performance stakes, I would would say the 150BHP FR with a remap to 175-180ish would be a better buy than a petrol model.

Superb build quality, handling and performance. This isn't a hot hatch but its a small car thats very well behaved and very fun at the same time. As for the bad points, I have to drive it for longer...


MK5Ibiza1.jpg


MK5Ibiza2.jpg


MK5Ibiza3.jpg


MK5Ibiza4.jpg


MK5Ibiza5.jpg


MK5Ibiza6.jpg
 
Last edited:

golfgtipaul

Active Member
Jul 14, 2009
90
0
Very good review mate. The only things i would say about mine was it is a bit crashy over bumps and I agree you have to change down quite a lot to pull away quickly. Other than that lovely car! Wish I had the 2l tdi FR - grrrr
 

Silent Shark

Active Member
Apr 3, 2010
176
0
Can I ask which colour that is?

I was hoping to get a FR in Track Grey, but have yet to see any car in that specific colour yet. I'm wondering if that's what you have here.
 

Biker

Full Member
Oct 6, 2003
1,593
12
Northumberland
Visit site
I think that is a pretty fair appraisal of the 1.6 CR TDI Sport:coolthumb

I have had mine for two weeks now and have no regrets at all about buying it. I was a bit concerned before I took delivery of it, as to whether I could live with the car as It is a world apart from my last car. I sold a mint condition LCR 225 with 30,000 on the clock, that I bought new in 2003 and absolutely loved.

Happily I can live with the Ibiza and I think I have made a very good choice!

Here is a picture of my Ibiza.

Ibiza_07.jpg
 
Last edited: