If the MAF is at fault, would it show on VAGCOM?
I've just had mine on there, looks like the MAP sensor is at fault, although would it cause the stuttering?
no sadly. the mafs often die slowly and dont usually get noticed by the ecu until they`ve gone.
you can log the maf with vagcom as you drive, to actually see what its doing. post the results on here and the clever ones can usually tell you if its doing its job