At least you have a space saver, no such luck with the hybrid!
I bought the
dealers demonstrator (V2, 19" wheels) at 9 months old, less than 5k miles. They said they had the alloys refurbished and they looked mint tbh. Well I managed to very lighty kerb the nearside front when someone pulled across infront of me! I took the car to a highly recommended diamond cut alloy repairer and they said they couldn't match the black so all 4 alloys would need to be stripped and repainted. So I had a cheapo smart repair done which looks OK from a distance but isn't aging too well.
Anyway, I managed to buy 2 virtually new ones very cheaply but some idiot had scuffed the inner barrel whilst removing the tyres. The faces are immaculate though. I got them back home only to find that the matt/silk black is totally different to those on my car.
Upshot is I'm still at a loss what to do and I have 2 lovely alloys I dont know what to do with. I'll be interested how you get on.