MAF or Something Else?

Oct 17, 2006
893
0
Walthamstow
cool, im logging tonight with Lee so will post results up tonight and see what you guys think - Fingers crossed its the N75 that is buggered!
 

T7ODD

Full Member
What block is inlet temps on as I wouldn't mind doing that too just out of interest.

I have to wait till Sat night now do log mine but I'm now thinking it's a boost leak as I'd have thought the valves/sensors would cause the boost to be erratic whereas it's constant. Maybe it was OK before as there was less pressure but now with more pressure requested it's being lost. I'm suspecting a blow in the FMIC piping somewhere OR the intercooler is second hand, could it have a hole in it? lol it looks OK though. I thought I heard hissing when the car was at idle but I think it might have been the alternator belt. I need a good look in daylight with a mate opening the throttle a bit.
 

acidstrato

My Fast says shut up!
Dec 9, 2004
5,942
0
Newport, South Wales
block 118 covers inlet temps


by the way you describe it mate it really does sound like a boost leak! i remember setting off from home for GTI international, and it took me a while to realise my car wasnt boosting 100% so i pulled over, opened the bonnet and could hear the leak, and within 5 mins i'd noticed one of the vac hoses was disconnected (it hadnt popped off i'd just forgotten to connect it the night before when i was detailing)

car was instantly improved, but it took me ages to notice that the car wasnt right.

bit late telling u this now i know, but usually its wise to get used intercoolers pressure tested. but tbh if it was the core you'd know, it would be pretty awful infact.

actual vs requested log can confirm boost leaks..but tbh easiest thing to do is just replace all the old tatty vac hose with new silicon vac hose from forge or someone. cheap and it rules it out. logs first though :)
 

T7ODD

Full Member
bit late telling u this now i know, but usually its wise to get used intercoolers pressure tested. but tbh if it was the core you'd know, it would be pretty awful infact...

actual vs requested log can confirm boost leaks..but tbh easiest thing to do is just replace all the old tatty vac hose with new silicon vac hose from forge or someone. cheap and it rules it out. logs first though :)


I've checked all the vacuum pipes as I've replaced them already the other week with 3mm silicone hose when I had the secondary air flow problem. I hope the ID isnt too restrictive but then I wouldn't expect that kind of pressure loss from 1mm difference. The intercooler looked fine, only covered 10,000 miles and just a few bent fins, that's all I could see. The only hose I didn't get to replace (as I ran out) was the one from the FPR to the manifold.
 

acidstrato

My Fast says shut up!
Dec 9, 2004
5,942
0
Newport, South Wales
i use 3mm so the ID is fine

as u have a laguna ic dont u? then im reluctant to mention any dodgy pipe work may need checking.

as it is we can wait for logs to rule out second guessing
 

acidstrato

My Fast says shut up!
Dec 9, 2004
5,942
0
Newport, South Wales
Code:
 Friday	1	December	2006	12:51:47							
6K0 906 032 AA 		1.8L 20VT EU3       0002									
											
	Group A:	'020				Group B:	'118				
		Idle Idle Idle 	Idle 	                                           RPM	Temperature Load	Absolute Pres.	
	TIME					                          TIME					
MARKER	STAMP	 CF	 CF	 CF	 CF	                        STAMP	 /min	°C	%	 mbar	
	0.31	0	0	0	0	                         0.61	 1720	27	87.5	1050	
	0.92	0	0	0	0	                         1.21	 1880	26	95.3	1190	
	1.51	0	0	0	0	                         1.81	 2080	24	95.3	1370	
	2.11	0	0	3	0	                         2.41	 2320	24	95.3	1620	
	2.71	0	0	3	0	                         3.01	 2600	23	95.3	1880	
	3.31	0	0	3	0	                         3.61   2920	23	83.5	2210	
	3.91	0	0	3	0	                         4.21	 3280	23	82.4	2420	
	4.51	0	0	2.3	0	                         4.81	3600	23	84.7	2340	
	5.12	0	0	2.3	0	                         5.42	3960	23	85.9	2330	
	5.72	0	0	2.3	0	                         6.02	4280	24	86.3	2270	
	6.32	0	0	2.3	0	                         6.62	4600	24	86.3	2190	
	6.92	0	0	1.5	0	                         7.22	4880	24	86.7	2080	
	7.52	0	0	1.5	0	                         7.82	5120	26	88.2	1990	
	8.22	0	0	1.5	0	                         8.52	5400	27	90.2	1920	
	8.82	0	0	1.5	0	                         9.12	5600	27	91.4	1850	
	9.42	0	0	1.5	0	                         9.72	5800	29	92.5	1790	
	10.02	0	0	1.5	0	                        10.32	6000	29	92.9	1750	
	10.61	0	0	0.8	0	                        10.92	6160	30	91	1710
 
Last edited:
Oct 17, 2006
893
0
Walthamstow
thanks for the results - what is block 20 showing?
as for block 118 - i assume everything is ok with your car and the percentage reflects that - does BHP effect the percentage or should the percentage reading always be near abouts the same as yours regardless of power?
 

acidstrato

My Fast says shut up!
Dec 9, 2004
5,942
0
Newport, South Wales
ok thats my log above, being stupid i done a really good log in 3rd gear, then tried the same in 2nd gear but it appeared to overwrite the first log so thats all i came home with :( usually id use 3rd gear.

block 020 display cylinder pull,
timing looks ok, theres abit on cylinder 3 to may be worried about but iv had 2 coilpacks pop on me in the last month so i wouldnt be surprised if that one is next but il leave it an see. tbh a 3 max isnt much to be concerned about, any more though and id really want my timing knocked down.

the second block looks nice to me, temps dont go above 30 and thats going into the red zone. duty peaks at 92% up the top of the rev range, so the WG isnt stressed.. boost looks 'ok' peaks at 21psi and with 14psi at 5k, although bit disappointed that its only about 11psi at 6k. maybe i backed off or maybe its cos it was in 2nd gear. but generally im pleased with that.

sorry to clam this thread up with my junk..but hopefully it will help when you guys are doing your own logs
 

acidstrato

My Fast says shut up!
Dec 9, 2004
5,942
0
Newport, South Wales
no duty has no reflection on power i dont think? a good simple definition i think would be that it represents how hard the waste gate is working to meet the requested boost. if that makes any sense
 
Oct 17, 2006
893
0
Walthamstow
Results Are In!!!!!!!!!!!

Right, have a butchers at these(slightly out of line but you get the jist of it)....

Code:
Friday	1	December	2006	19:55:01						
6K0 906 032    		1.8L R4/20VT SEA    0002								
										
	Group A:	'115				Group B:	'118			
		RPM	Load	Absolute Pres.	Absolute Pres.		RPM	Temperature	Load	Absolute Pres.
	TIME					TIME				
MARKER	STAMP	 /min	%	 mbar	 mbar	STAMP	 /min	°C	%	 mbar
	0.6	1720	73.7	1720	1020	0.9	1320	30	10.2	1080
	1.5	1520	100	1860	1180	1.8	1560	29	11	1220
	2.4	1680	110.5	2000	1290	2.7	1720	28	15.7	1320
	3.3	1800	114.3	2090	1350	3.6	1880	27	20.4	1360
	4.2	2000	117.3	2160	1380	4.5	2040	27	24.3	1390
	5.3	2200	119.5	2120	1410	5.6	2240	27	27.5	1410
	6.19	2360	121.1	2090	1430	6.49	2440	27	29.8	1430
	7.09	2520	123.3	2040	1440	7.39	2600	28	31.4	1450
	7.99	2720	121.8	2000	1440	8.29	2760	29	30.2	1440
	8.89	2880	120.3	1970	1430	9.19	2960	29	28.6	1430
	9.79	3080	123.3	1930	1420	10.09	3160	29	28.2	1420
	10.69	3280	123.3	1910	1420	10.99	3360	30	28.2	1420
	11.59	3480	124.8	1880	1420	11.89	3880	30	28.2	1410
	12.49	3640	123.3	1870	1410	12.79	3720	31	28.2	1410
	13.39	3840	124.1	1860	1410	13.69	3880	32	28.2	1410
	14.29	4000	124.1	1860	1400	14.69	4080	33	27.1	1400
	15.29	4160	124.1	1840	1390	15.59	4240	33	23.9	1380
	16.19	4360	124.8	1820	1380	16.49	4400	33	21.2	1380
	17.09	4520	127.1	1800	1370	17.39	4560	34	18.4	1360
	17.99	4680	127.1	1800	1350	18.3	4720	34	15.3	1340
	18.9	4840	125.6	1790	1340	19.29	4920	35	12.5	1330
	19.89	5000	124.8	1780	1330	20.2	5080	36	10.2	1330
	20.89	5160	123.3	1780	1330	21.2	5240	36	10.2	1330
	21.9	5320	122.6	1770	1320	22.29	5400	37	10.2	1320
	22.89	5480	121.1	1780	1330	23.2	5520	37	10.2	1320
	23.9	5600	120.3	1780	1310	24.19	5640	39	10.2	1310
	24.8	5560	107.5	1000	1260	25.18	4960	37	0	1230




Going from what i know, 115 is clearly showing im loosing boost somewhere...trying to eliminate my options by measuring 118(N75 Duty)
In comparison to Acid results, my temp is alot higher - is this because i dont mine in 3rd gear whereas acid's was done in 2nd? - as for the percentage, im sooo lacking - right, can i assume i need to change the N75 Valve?
 

m0rk

sarcasm comes free
Staff member
May 19, 2001
27,787
33
Clanfield, UK
I'd say that the N75 is goosed, or the wastegate itself is

but do check all the vacuum piping first

you're wasting your time doing logs in 2nd gear, and argueably 3rd as well though.
 

acidstrato

My Fast says shut up!
Dec 9, 2004
5,942
0
Newport, South Wales
i have a front mounted intercooler bud, this will make the difference in intake temps

its possible that the wg duty is low because you have a rather large boost leak. but then you might be not making your requested boost because you have a feckled n75.

if i was you id just go buy one cos they are only about 30/40quid for a stock valve. rule it out and then you know
 

acidstrato

My Fast says shut up!
Dec 9, 2004
5,942
0
Newport, South Wales
I'd say that the N75 is goosed, or the wastegate itself is

but do check all the vacuum piping first

you're wasting your time doing logs in 2nd gear, and argueably 3rd as well though.

well what gear do you do logs in when you have to? redline in 4th would be touching 115-120mph
 
Lecatona HPFP (High-pressure Fuel Pump Upgrades)